Your mentor list is longer than your mentor relationships
If your programme has a list of mentors in its network congratulations you're already on the right track. You may have also put in a significant amount of time categorising and organising the list according to industry of focus, kinds of start-ups they want to be involved in, if they act as angel investors or not. It's good work to do but no amount of organising can alter the fact that most likely only a small minority of them have had more than one real conversation with one of your founders.
A list a network does not make. Even if the names look nice on the website. Mentors usually are recruited because of the credibility associated with their name, not necessarily their reliability or commitment when it comes to supporting the founders in your cohorts. In-ecosystem investments and follow-on financing, for the most part, are actually coming from the small minority of your mentors who remain engaged with the founders they support after the first coffee chat.
Take the example of a mentor registered for 4 years who came to an open house at the launch of the programme but has had absolutely no contact with a founder since that first day. On paper your programme has one more mentor, in reality it doesn't.
The step you take that turns mentor count into substance is the structure and enforcement of contact between mentor and mentee, recording the outputs (be they learnings, introductions, commitments or other) and importantly removal of the mentor relationships that don't deliver. A quarterly check-in logged against each mentor is enough to tell a name on a page from a relationship that doesn't do anything.

